Peer-reviewed
Manion, Anita, Jake Shaw, Sapna Varkey, and David Kimball. 2025. “Representation Matters: Assessing the Gender and Racial Divide in Missouri’s Municipal Boards.” Politics, Groups, and Identities: 1-28.
Abstract
Municipal boards and commissions enable citizen participation in local government, provide expertise, foster community engagement, and contribute to effective governance. However, there is a dearth of reliable data about how many boards and commissions exist, who serves on them, and how representation on boards and commissions breaks down by gender and race. We gathered data on boards and commissions for municipalities with a population of 1000 or more in Missouri and analyzed the data to determine levels of gender and racial parity. Our findings demonstrate that women and people of color are underrepresented broadly on boards and commissions. The gender disparity is especially glaring on “power boards” that have enormous impacts on public policy and the allocation of resources. We also find that cities with female mayors constrain some of the gendered appointment patterns found in other cities. Finally, we find that gender inequity tends to be even more pronounced among leadership and support positions on local commissions. Racial representation on municipal boards follows a different pattern that varies primarily across cities, with increased representation of people of color on boards in more populous cities with higher levels of socioeconomic status.
Click here for access to this article.
Reports
Manion, Anita, Jake Shaw, Sapna Varkey, and David Kimball. 2023. Gender Parity on Civic Boards and Commissions. Report issued by United WE, August 24, 2023.
Executive Summary
Municipal boards and commissions enable citizen participation in local government, provide expertise, foster community engagement, and contribute to effective governance. Researchers have long noted that women and racial minorities are underrepresented at all levels of government. However, there is a dearth of reliable data about how many boards and commissions exist, who serves on them, how representation on these boards and commissions breaks down by gender and race. We gathered data on boards and commissions for municipalities with a population of 1,000 or more in Missouri in spring 2023 and analyzed the data to determine levels of gender and racial parity. Our findings demonstrate that the membership of boards and commissions in Missouri does not reflect the racial, ethnic, and gender composition of the state. Women and people of color are underrepresented broadly on boards and commissions. In our sample, women comprise only 36.9% of members of boards and commissions, and white Missourians comprise 92.3% of members. While 11.7% of the state’s population is Black, we find that Black Missourians hold only 5.4% of the seats on boards and commissions.
The gender disparity is especially glaring on “power boards” that have enormous impacts on public policy and the allocation of financial resources. We find that women in Missouri have the highest proportion of seats on boards and commissions focused on the arts, community development, human rights, and libraries–stereotypically feminine areas. Conversely, men in Missouri (predominantly white men) have the highest proportion of seats on “power boards”–planning and zoning, transportation, budget and finance, adjustments and appeals, and public works. Furthermore, men are more likely than women to be appointed to leadership positions on municipal boards and commissions. The voices of women and people of color are diminished on influential boards that influence critical issues, including home prices, segregation, and environmental justice. We seek to provide critical data to help inform policymakers, elected leaders, advocacy groups, and potential members of boards and commissions in their decisions about how to form and populate local boards and commissions in an equitable and transparent manner.
Click here for access to this report.
Works in progress
Shaw, Jake. “Short Term Natural Disaster Retrospections in U.S. Presidential and Gubernatorial Elections: Hurricanes, Wildfires, and Tornadoes, 2016 – 2022.”
Shaw, Jake. “Red Hurricane? Short-Term Retrospective Voting in Florida’s 2022 Midterm Election.”
Manion, Anita, Sapna Varkey, Jake Shaw, and David Kimball. “Campaign Contributions in Mayoral Elections Vary By Race and Sex.”
Bryant, Lisa, Anita Manion, David Kimball, and Jake Shaw. “A Tale of Two Counties: A Study of Vote Centers in Fresno County and St. Louis County.”
Rhoads, Ty and Jake Shaw. “COVID Mandates and the 2020 U.S. Presidential Election: A State-Level Comparison of Voter Responses to COVID Health Policy.”
Rhoads, Ty and Jake Shaw. Public Health and Economic Concerns and Policy Responses to Them in a Pandemic: Battleground State Voters in the 2020 Presidential Election.”